Determine if an Article is Scholarly: How to Determine if an Article is Scholarly

Learn how to differentiate between popular and scholarly articles and how to find peer reviewed or refereed journal articles.
info question Facebook Twitter user Ask Skip the menu to the main content

What makes an article scholarly?

Scholarly articles differ from other articles. Ask yourself the following questions to determine if an article is scholarly.

Who is the author? Who is the audience?
Scholarly articles are written by experts for experts.

Who are experts?
Students, researchers, professors, or professionals in the field.

Who is the publisher?
Universities, academic presses, and professional organizations publish scholarly articles.

Why was the article published? What is its purpose?
Scholarly articles are published to make research available to other researchers.

Does it cite sources?
Sources are cited clearly and transparently in a structured bibliography.

What is the format?
Scholarly articles follow a structure that frequently includes headings for different sections, like abstract, introduction, methods or methodology, results, conclusion, bibliography. There are few (if any) advertisements, little to no color, and graphics are used to elucidate points made in the text.
 

What is peer review?

Not all scholarly articles are considered peer-reviewed!

Peer-reviewed journals contain scholarly articles that have been reviewed by a panel of scholars or experts in a particular discipline before being accepted for publication.

Peer reviewed journals are generally scholarly, but not all scholarly journals are peer reviewed.

A comparison of peer-reviewed and scholarly journals. Adapted from "What's the difference between scholarly and peer-reviewed articles?" by University of Toronto Libraries. Retrieved from https://onesearch.library.utoronto.ca/faq/whats-difference-between-scholarly-and-peer-reviewed-articles

 

You can read more about the peer review process here.

Library Databases

Library databases provide electronic access to articles published in periodicals.

Library databases are different from most search engines. How do they differ?

  • WE PAY for these resources (and that's why we log in through the library homepage)
  • The way you enter queries:
    • Most library databases can't parse natural language queries.
      • This is like asking your home assistant, "Hey robot, what's the weather today?"
    • BUT: they can help get you to specific content related to your topic!
    • You can search by topic keywords, author, title, DOI, or other criteria
    • You can easily limit searches to get more relevant results
  • The results that are returned